http://fireflyeco.com/
rss
email
twitter
  • About

Greenpeace takes aim at IT

no comments
Posted on May 27 2009 by Daniel
Tweet

Greenpeace, not known for their subtle arts of persuasion, has launched a no-holds-barred campaign that “encourages” tech leaders to reduce their carbon footprint.  Apparently, the IT sector has the capacity to reduce carbon emissions 15% below baseline through technologies like smart buildings and smart grids.  The Greenpeace site aims to shame leaders into doing their part.

As a proponent of helpful ecometrics, I have to question the CEO scorecard Greenpeace has chosen.  While metrics like “Renewable Energy Use” are tractable and easily compared, their “Political Advocacy” and “Public Climate Speech” categories seem subjective at best.  Both leaders get dinged because they haven’t mentioned Kyoto or Copenhagen targets, and the scoring guidelines give points to leaders who “push for the specific level of mandatory cuts required globally or in the relevant country.”  But does mentioning a target equate to pushing?  This isn’t clear in their rules.

The majority of points (50) are given for providing “Climate Solutions” and here they deserve credit for taking a cogent look at reporting standards.  They clearly define their targets: ”

  • Provide calculation of current net GHG emissions by solutions provided by company to other parts of the economy and make this information public. Maximum = 25 points.
  • Provide explanation of metric used to calculate net GHG emissions reductions of solutions and make this information public. Companies must provide a comprehensive metric reflecting current best practice in the industry. Moving forward Greenpeace would like to see the industry develop a standard protocol for net emissions reductions similar to the current GHG protocol standard. Maximum = 15 points.
  • Ambitious target for net GHG emissions by solutions provided across the economy by 2012. Maximum =10 points.
  • A company’s leadership on global GHG emission reductions and the public advocacy work it undertakes to influence politicians on the need for strong global emissions reduction targets in the second implementation phase of the Kyoto Protocol, due to start in 2012, but being negotiated this year, culminating in final positions at the Climate Change Negotiations in Copenhagen in December.”

Well, 2 out of 4 isn’t bad.  Unfortunately, we don’t know what “ambitious targets” are, nor how to measure “leadership on global GHG emission reductions.”

It will be interesting to see if the CEO’s respond…

Can't get enough? Try these related posts:

  1. Be Green, Earn Green, See Red
  2. Climate Action Plan Published
  3. Questioning Cap and Trade? Part 1.
  4. Can the grid be too smart?
  5. The Unintended Consequence of Offsets

  Tags: computers, efficiency Category: Energy

Twitter

What you’re saying:

  • lu9 on Homestar. Sewiously.
  • Leslie Davis on BizBuzz: Plastic Bags into Oil
  • Anonymous on Free Money for Duke Energy Customers

Blogroll

  • FlowingData
    Weave for visualization development
    February 7, 2012

  • Green Building Advisor Blogs
    The Strange Geography of Thermostat Settings
    February 7, 2012

  • Chart Porn
    Beyond the Hairball
    February 6, 2012

  • JMP Blog
    New in JMP 10 for experiment design: Evaluate Design
    February 6, 2012

  • information aesthetics
    Super Chatter: Analyzing Conversations about the Super Bowl on Twitter
    February 6, 2012

  • mapawatt
    Build your own compost pile
    February 5, 2012

  • Visual Business Intelligence
    Should Data Visualizations Be Beautiful?
    February 1, 2012

  • Lean Insider
    The Denver Health & Hospital Authority -- The Results Are In
    January 25, 2012

  • Gemba Panta Rei
    Consumption Rate, Replenishment Time, SWIP and Why Glaciers Need Love
    January 23, 2012

  • Energy Circle
    ReCircle: The Rebound Effect, Smart Homes, Energy Monitoring, Spray Foam Insulation and more!
    January 13, 2012

Categories

  • Carbon
  • Commercial
  • Design
  • EcoMetrics
  • Energy
  • Financial
  • Food and Agriculture
  • InfoVis
  • Lean
  • Nature
  • PlotWatt
  • Policy
  • Pollution
  • Presentation
  • Residential
  • Solid Waste
  • Transportation
  • Water

Tags

agriculture appliances bacteria biomimicry buildings cap and trade carbon footprint cash for clunkers CFL climate change computers corn data efficiency electricity grid home comfort humidity humor HVAC LCA Lean LED legislation lighting maps marketing offsets oil organic recycling renewables SciLights smart grid social justice software solar statistics subsidies TEDTalks transportation UNC visualization waste Water

  • About
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License